If I told you we check our phones 5 billion times a minute you’d probably just shrug and agree. We’ve seen the shocking stats over and over and at this point no number would surprise us. But there’s one study that haunts me…
Here’s what NYU professor Adam Alter told me:
There’s a study that was done asking people, mainly young adults, to make a decision: if you had to break a bone or break your phone what would you prefer? Forty-six percent of people would prefer to have a broken bone than a broken phone. But even for the fifty-four percent of people who say they’d prefer to have a broken phone, it wasn’t a snap decision. They agonized over it.
May I suggest that this has finally gotten out of hand? (Or arm, for that matter?) Whatever lifehacks we’re trying clearly aren’t working because we ended up, well… here.
We’re not looking at the problem correctly. For starters:
You do not have a short attention span.
Have you had multiple car crashes this week because you can’t pay attention to the road? Just got fired because you can’t complete your work?
See? You can pay attention when you “have to” – whatever arbitrarily determines “have to.” And I’ll bet you can pay attention when you want to, my dear Netflix binge-rs and video game champions.
That’s not a short attention span. This means we lack attentional control, the continent-sized difference between what we say we want to focus on and what we actually focus on.
This thing you call “your life” is made of memories. And your memories are made up of only the things you paid attention to. Exactly 2.32 bazillion things are happening in the world right now but all that exists for you and all that will ever exist is what you paid attention to. Attention determines your life and your happiness.
We think so much about the events in life and so little about attention, yet we all know that we can be experiencing something objectively great but not appreciate it because our attention is elsewhere, feeling we don’t deserve this, or worried we’ll screw it up, etc. In that way, attention is more important than the events themselves.
These days we spend so much time trying to get others attention yet the true determinant of our happiness is where we direct our own.
We have a “mind control” problem. But it’s not other people’s ability to control your mind. It’s your own.
So what do we do? Throw our phones in a wood chipper?
Nah. Our phones are merely the canary in the coal mine, warning us about the bigger problems with the attentional weakness that threatens our happiness and relationships.
We’re gonna tunnel deeper down the rabbit hole past the phone issue so we can nuke this thing for good. So follow me on a little detour into the 19th century, neuroscience, and the improper use of explosives. You in?
Good. Sign the insurance waiver and let’s get to it…
Why Instant Gratification Takes Too Long
This is from a new medical study on people addicted to their phones:
…the patients verbalized what the most appropriate social responses would be under certain circumstances. Yet, when actually performing, they instead pursued behavior aimed at immediate gratification, despite knowing the longer-term results would be self-defeating.
Sounds just like our phone addictions, right?
Well, I lied. That’s not from a study on phone addiction; it’s a description of people with prefrontal brain damage. No, no, I’m not saying your phone is damaging your brain. But the two have something in common. And we’ll get to the bottom of it by looking at the most famous story in all of psychology — and why even if you know the story, you probably don’t know the whole story.
Here goes, extra-short version for the attentionally-challenged:
September 13, 1848. Phineas Gage is foreman of a railroad construction team drilling holes in rock with explosives. He makes an error, things go boom, and the fourteen-pound, three-foot-long, inch-wide iron pipe he’s working with gets sent through his skull like a bullet, giving new meaning to the expression “mind-blowing.” It flies in beneath his left eye and out the top of his head, landing 80-feet away…
But he doesn’t die. In fact, he’s not even rendered unconscious. But as he recovers, the results of the brain damage become clear. He’s extremely impulsive, unable to plan or focus, and very short-tempered. His friends said he was “no longer Gage.”
Some might think, “Oh no! The injury transformed him into an inhuman monster!” Actually, no. It wouldn’t be totally accurate to say it “transformed”…
More like “revealed.”
Humans are wonderful creatures (usually) but we’re still animals. And the older parts of the brain are a tad more animalistic. What you think of as “you” is mostly the prefrontal cortex (PFC), and it often creates “you” by being the brakes that keep the animal in line. “Free will” is nice but often it’s more like “free won’t.”
Phineas became impulsive because that rod shredded a big section of his brakes. But here’s our problem: even when your PFC is intact and healthy it’s still pretty weak compared to the parts of your brain creating those urges. (If you were a car company and paired an engine this powerful with brakes this bad you’d be up to your ears in class action suits.) Our current environment and often poor habits exhaust your poor little PFC. And when your PFC is overwhelmed, you’re not going to be who you want to be.
So what does the usual telling of Gage’s story leave out? And what does it have to do with us?
Gage actually recovered. Not completely, of course. He wouldn’t be crushing it on the Jeopardy Tournament of Champions or anything, but he became functional again. How?
He moved to Chile and became a stagecoach driver. And he was in an environment that forced him to focus, to plan, to socialize — to relearn control. In fact, his recovery influenced how patients with frontal lobe damage are helped today. It’s critical that “someone or something gave enough structure to their lives for them to relearn lost social and personal skills.”
And that’s what we need. The modern world has upped its attention-grabbing offense to Major League levels while our defense is still playing tee-ball with the kiddies. We need to structure our lives and strengthen our lil’ PFC to focus in this world of distraction.
Oh, one more thing the usual story doesn’t mention — the root cause of Gage’s accident? When he was prepping the iron rod and the explosives, the guys behind him were making a racket and he turned to see what they were up to. Yeah, that’s right…
Phineas Gage wasn’t paying attention.
(To learn more about the science of a successful life, check out my bestselling book here.)
Time to strengthen our attentional control…
1) Overall Health
If your body is weak and tired, your PFC is too. So exercise. Get your sleep.
Even a single bout of exercise improves cognitive control.
Boosts in cognitive control abilities occur even after engagement in a single bout of physical exertion, as assessed in healthy children and those diagnosed with ADHD, with benefits extending to academic achievement… Similar training benefits of acute and chronic exercise on cognitive control have been shown in both young adults and middle-age adults.
And a single bad night’s sleep reduces it.
…even a single bad night’s sleep can impair cognitive control and how ongoing sleep deprivation can have severe and long-term consequences.
And while we’re on the subject of oft-repeated basics, stop multitasking. The PFC is a weakling. You can really only focus on one thing at a time and cognitive “switching costs” are steeper than payday loans.
…if the two goals both require cognitive control to enact them, such as holding the details of a complex scene in mind (working memory) at the same time as searching the ground for a rock (selective attention), then they will certainly compete for limited prefrontal cortex resources… The process of neural network switching is associated with a decrease in accuracy, often for both tasks, and a time delay compared to doing one task at a time.
(To learn the two-word morning ritual that will make you happy all day, click here.)
Okay, you’re keeping your brain healthy. Great. Now it’s time to change the world around us to make attentional control easier…
2) Control Your Context
One of the clearest and most profound lessons to come out of social psychology over the past few decades is that context matters. What surrounds you influences you — whether you realize it or not.
What helped Phineas focus and improve? A structured environment. Clear distractions from your surroundings and it’s easier to focus. What’s the first step toward successful dieting? Don’t live in a bakery. Same principle applies here.
Turning your phone off and putting it in another room is — believe it or not — still legal in most countries. But most people think they can just ignore it. Yeah, it’s possible…
But it’ll cost you. According to MRI studies, ignoring is not a passive process. Whether you notice it or not, it takes brain effort.
What we learned from this experiment was that the act of ignoring is not a passive process; rather, the goal to ignore something is an active one that is mediated by the top-down suppression of activity below baseline levels of passively viewing… it takes resources to filter out what is irrelevant.
When you need to focus, get your phone or anything that is not mission critical out of sight. Plain and simple: make any behaviors you want to encourage easier to do and any behaviors you want to discourage harder to do. Leverage laziness to improve your life.
Turn off notifications by default. Instead of unlocking your phone with a fingerprint or FaceID, switch it to a long password that’s a pain to type. Or best of all, just put it away and only get it at designated times.
The harder it is to check, the less you will check.
(To learn the secret to never being frustrated again, click here.)
But there will be times where we simply can’t hide our phones or remove distractions. What then?
If you can’t weaken the enemy, strengthen yourself. How about we get your car some stronger brakes?
Research by top neuroscientist Richard Davidson shows that meditation pretty much addresses the exact problems we’re having here.
“Mindfulness,” he said, “boosts the classic attention network in the brain’s fronto-parietal system that works together to allocate attention. These circuits are fundamental in the basic movement of attention: disengaging your focus from one thing, moving it to another, and staying with that new object of attention.” Another key improvement is in selective attention, inhibiting the pull of distractors… Mindfulness strengthens connections between the prefrontal executive zones and the amygdala, particularly the circuits that can say “no” to impulse— a vital skill for navigating through life…
And the benefits described above extend well beyond phones — to being able to let go of nagging worries and to focus on the good in life. Meditation strengthens your PFC and increases happiness.
…average subjects who had completed an eight-week meditation course showed significantly increased activity in the left prefrontal regions that are linked to this optimistic, goal-oriented orientation.
I won’t lie — meditation can be difficult and it takes time. But increased attentional control is worth it, for you and those you love. “You don’t pay attention to me” is a phrase all-too-often voiced as marriages spiral downwards. Follow the breath and keep your spouse.
(To learn the easy way to start meditating, click here.)
Meditation is strong. But there is one method that is even stronger. Of course, it is also the most difficult. Its effects go far beyond transforming your phone habits.
Quite simply, it’s transforming you…
4) Your Not-So-Secret Identity
Hypothetical: Your friend has left the room and their wallet is sitting in front of you. I guarantee they won’t notice if you steal a dollar out of it. Your friend is rich. They don’t need the dollar. So why not?
Most of us wouldn’t do it. And often it’ll come down to a simple statement:
“I’m just not the kind of person who would do that. That’s not who I am.”
And you would not struggle with this choice. It would be easy and painless. The most powerful method for gaining control over impulses is to leverage identity.
Ask yourself: “Who am I?” (No, not in the Jason Bourne way.) And, “What kind of person do I want to be?”
In Nir Eyal’s book, “Indistractable” he discusses a 2011 Stanford study that split a pool of registered voters into two groups, asking one cohort, “How important is it to you to vote?” and the other, “How important is it to you to be a voter?” Those asked the latter question were much more likely to turn out on election day.
(Researcher Christopher Bryan) said, “People may be more likely to vote when voting is represented as an expression of self – as symbolic of a person’s fundamental character – rather than as simply a behavior.”
Vegans don’t stress over “Should I eat meat?” That’s not who they are. A lot of previously hard decisions become answered for you once you accept a new identity. Becoming a parent frequently overhauls people’s lives. Suddenly your number one priority is clear and anything that contradicts it is not even up for discussion.
Identity can be hard to shift on your own. What helped Phineas and people with prefrontal damage? “Someone or something gave enough structure to their lives for them to relearn lost social and personal skills.”
So let peer pressure do the work for you. Spend more time with the people you want to be. People who have goals and ambitions beyond Instagram likes. People who would look at you funny if you impulsively whipped out your phone every three seconds.
The Longevity Project, which studied 1000+ people from childhood to death, said this:
The groups you associate with often determine the type of person you become. For people who want improved health, association with other healthy people is usually the strongest and most direct path of change.
If you don’t have a group, one friend will do. Nir suggests an “identity pact.” Hold each other accountable and become better together.
We don’t check our phones when we hang out. That’s just not who we are.
The benefits of deciding who you want to be and acting on it extend way beyond your silly little phone issues.
I’m not saying this will be easy. But I am saying it will be worth it.
(To learn how to deal with passive-aggressive people, click here.)
Okay, we’ve covered a lot and our limited attentional control is waning. Time to round it up and learn how attention is the secret to happiness…
This is how to stop checking your phone:
- Overall Health: Get your sleep and exercise. Avoid explosives and railroad spikes.
- Control Your Context: Your phone is not a pacemaker or an insulin pump. You can turn it off and put it away. Distractions drain your brain whether you notice it or not.
- Mindfulness: Imagine being able to let go of the negative, to focus on the positive and to get a second chance to decide before impulsively engaging in bad habits. Won’t make you one of the Avengers, but it’s a superpower nonetheless.
- Your Not-So-Secret Identity: Who are you? I could summarize this in greater detail but I’m just not the kind of writer who does that. It’s not who I am.
We spend so much time, money and energy to do things to be happier — because the secret to happiness is more experiences that make you happy, right?
Originally published on Medium.
Stay up to date or catch-up on all our podcasts with Arianna Huffington here.